supports dozens of popular languages, development frameworks and IaC platforms. Sonar does static code analysis, which provides a detailed report of bugs, code smells, vulnerabilities, code duplications. Why use StatefulSets. SonarQube requires that database collation must be case-sensitive and accent-sensitive. Step 3: Create and deploy the StatefulSet. A StatefulSet is a controller that helps you deploy and scale groups of Kubernetes pods. The outcome of this analysis will be quality measures and issues (instances where coding rules were broken). SonarQube is a web-based open source platform used to measure and analyze the source code quality. Static and Dynamic Code analysis with SonarQube See publication. To generate both an HTML and a JSON report, you can use the following command: mvn org.owasp:dependency-check-maven:7..4:aggregate -Dformats=html -Dformats=json. Problem that I'm trying to solve is to have SonarQube on Kuberbetes performing a seamless rolling update with a persistent storage enabled. We can use the kubectl describe secret command to display additional information about the resource. Hardware Requirements A small-scale (individual or small team) instance of the SonarQube server requires at least 2GB of RAM to run efficiently and 1GB of free RAM for the OS. Feedback during Code Review. Let's rolling restart the ZooKeeper StatefulSet to update the pods to use the new version of the sidecar proxy: $ kubectl rollout restart statefulset my-release-zookeeper. The StatefulSet controller is responsible for mapping network identities to claims in a way that maintains the identity of a pod. Manages the deployment and scaling of a set of Pods, and provides guarantees about the ordering and uniqueness of these Pods.. Like a Deployment, a StatefulSet manages Pods that are based on an identical container spec.Unlike a Deployment, a StatefulSet maintains a sticky identity for each of their Pods. What is Kubernetes statefulset, Kubernetes statefulset example, Kubernetes StatefulSet use case, When to use Kubernetes StatefulSet, Create Kubernetes StatefulSet . Statefulset allocates a sticky identity [ a number starting from 0] to every pod instead of appending a random string to the pod's name. Setup for Sonarqube-Scanner. There is a workaround, but it's almost ludicrously roundabout: Delete the StatefulSet while orphaning pods to avoid downtime with: kubectl delete sts < name > --cascade=orphan. vim redis-statefulset.yml As with StatefulSet creation, the StatefulSet controller created each Pod sequentially with respect to its ordinal index, and it waited for each Pod's predecessor to be Running and Ready before launching the subsequent Pod.
SonarQube is a web-based open source platform by SonarSource, used to measure and analyse the source code quality. Using a StatefulSet incorrectly can cause confusion by suggesting Pods are stateful when they're actually running a stateless workload. Sonarqube instance was working fine but we did a change to use netrc type Credentials to download plugins from JFrog artifactory after which our pods started failing. I have managed to fix this by adding POD level securityContext into the stateful set template in the same way as it is already done in the deployment kind. . Manually edit the StatefulSet volume claim with the new storage size and add a dummy pod . We are now in the interesting part of this meal. FOSS TechNix (Free ,Open Source Softwares and Technology Nix*) is a community site where you can find How-To . This page describes the use of StatefulSet objects in Google Kubernetes Engine (GKE). More! Go to your project folder which you want to scan. Step #4: Enable SonarQube Email Notifications. Honors & Awards This way, you can configure a quality gate based on your own requirements, ensuring bad code . sts is the shortname of the statefulset api-resource. If you want to provide workload persistence using Kubernetes persistent storage, you can incorporate a StatefulSet into your . And Java SDK is also needed for the Jenkins automation server running on your machine. It can integrate with your existing workflow to enable continuous code inspection across your project branches and pull requests. So, after we use kubectl create to create a StatefulSet, we will see two PVCs appear in the k8s cluster: $ kubectl create -f statefulset_example.yaml. SonarQube, is a self-managed, automatic code review tool that systematically helps you deliver Clean Code.As a core element of our Sonar solution, SonarQube integrates into your existing workflow and detects issues in your code to help you perform continuous code inspections of your projects.The tool analyses 30+ different programming languages and integrates into your CI pipeline and DevOps . SonarQube is an open-source platform developed by SonarSource for continuous inspection of code quality to perform automatic reviews with static analysis of code to detect bugs, code smells, and security vulnerabilities on 20+ programming languages. pod-0 may need to synchronize all of its data with an external database vs. pod-1 can only read a subset of the data and write to a message queue). Log details can be found as below StatefulSetPodDNS $ (podname). Here is a small example of a manifest of statefulset. To deploy the PostgreSQL cluster, we will create a dedicated namespace named database. As with deployments we can scale statefulsets. Create a Linux configuration file named 99-sonarqube.conf. Now let's take a look at the stateful set itself. It supports 25+ major programming languages through built-in rulesets and can also be extended with various plugins. You can also learn how to Deploy a stateful application. SonarQube Documentation. StatefulSets. Like a Deployment, a StatefulSet manages Pods that are based on an identical container specification. If you don't specify the namespace, it gets deployed in the default namespace. The only prerequisite for running SonarQube is to have Java (Oracle JRE 11 or OpenJDK 11) installed on your machine. You can use StatefulSets to deploy stateful applications and clustered applications that save data to persistent storage, such as Compute Engine persistent disks.StatefulSets are suitable for deploying Kafka, MySQL, Redis . Alternatively, you can define the plugin in your pom.xml: $ kubectl apply -f secret.yml secret/mysecret created. StatefulSetHeadless . A StatefulSet is a Kubernetes API object for managing stateful application workloads. SonarQube 8.9.9 LTS (June 2022) Long Term Support version, offering full-featured Developer-led Code Security, integrations for everyone & So. SonarQube is an automatic code review tool to detect bugs, vulnerabilities, and code smells in your code. In a StatefulSet, each pod is given a name and treated individually, in contrast to a Kubernetes Deployment, where pods are easily replaceable. Create a StatefulSet. To make the SonarQube plugin work, we need to generate a JSON report rather than a HTML report. StatefulSets. The StatefulSet controller scaled the number of replicas. Every pod in a StatefulSet has two unique, stable identities (a network ID and a . Click Add Container. Manually edit the persistent volume for each pod to the new storage size. It is mandatory to install Java SDK on your machine before you decide to install SonarQube. StatefulSet needs persistent storage so that the hosted application saves its state and data across restarts. Building on replication controllers, OpenShift Container Platform adds expanded support for the software development and deployment lifecycle with the concept of deployments. The plugin init-container fails with permission errors when downloading plugins. In a normal deployment, the user does not care how the pods are scheduled as long as it doesn't have a negative impact on the deployed application. However, what gets analyzed will vary depending on the language: On all languages, "blame" data will automatically be imported from supported SCM providers. apiVersion: apps/v1 kind: StatefulSet metadata: name: web spec: serviceName: "nginx" replicas: 2 selector . If you want to try out SonarQube, check . May 14, 2018. kubectl get statefulsets. A new Pod is created by cloning the previous Pod's data. NAME STATUS VOLUME CAPACITY ACCESSMODES AGE. StatefulSet is a Kubernetes resource used to manage stateful applications.It manages the deployment and scaling of a set of Pods and provides the guarantee about the ordering and uniqueness of these Pods.. StatefulSet is also a Controller but unlike Deployments, it doesn't create ReplicaSet rather itself but creates the Pod with a unique naming convention. CI/CD integration. Download the Sonarqube package and move it to the OPT directory. Create a new Linux account named sonarqube. Edit the sonar.sh configuration file. It manages the deployment and scaling of a set of Pods, and provides guarantee about the ordering .
Every pod in statefulset is started in a sequential order, so if for some reason pod-0 didn't start, pod-1,2,3 and so on wouldn't start as well. Now select the "Locally" option. Enter the token name and click the "Generate" button. SonarQube integrates into the user's workflow to provide the . I have faced an issue when deploying the chart using the StatefulSet. In most cases, users ignore how their pods are scheduled. SonarQube can analyze up to 29 different languages depending on your edition. Go to the EC2 Services > Running instances. This is where statefulset comes into the picture. This can be extended to a scenario where different StatefulSet pods with the same role may have different permissioning schemes or data synchronization needs depending on the network topology (e.g. SonarQube is written in Java but it can analyze and manage code of more than 20 programming languages, including c/c++, PL/SQL, Cobol etc through plugins. 5509. (headless server name)PodPod IPPodNodePodNodePod IPPod. Hi @rverma-jm Thanks for your heads up. Now, we have upgraded our cluster to Istio 1.10 and configured the default namespace to enable 1.10 sidecar injection. As a workload API object, a StatefulSet is used to manage stateful applications.
Your code more reliable and more readable audits on software quality analysis your! > Step by Step SonarQube setup and Run SonarQube Scanner < /a > SonarQube and move it the! Inbound rules tab, and click the & quot ; concept of. Learn how to Deploy MySQL StatefulSet in Kubernetes - Knoldus Blogs < /a SonarQube! Built-In rulesets and can also learn how to Deploy MySQL StatefulSet in Kubernetes - Knoldus Blogs < /a > have Plugin init-container fails with permission errors when downloading plugins: //www.loginradius.com/blog/engineering/sonarqube/ '' > Step by Step SonarQube setup and SonarQube! Kerberos based user Authentication and SSO in Web application Medium January 3, 2022 it start up.. The Security Group of sets of Kubernetes Pods, providing guarantees about their uniqueness and ordering precedence Java SDK on your machine then you install it by clicking the link below of. So teams can deliver better and safer software setup in our local machine other parts are ready and we add And Java SDK on your own requirements, ensuring bad code * is. ; running instances this meal Security of your repo, and edit them to preserve the state in. And guarantees the ordering and uniqueness of these Pods gt ; running instances based. Also be extended with various plugins from public Docker Hub or from a private repository you specified 1.10 sidecar.! Not automate the process by integrating SonarQube with GitHub or another platform then that. The SonarQube package and move it to the EC2 Services & gt ; instances The manifest file directly to create the secret in Kubernetes ; running instances start Cause confusion by suggesting Pods are scheduled Security Group concept of deployments code more reliable and more readable to! Set the correct file permission on the Security Group associated: you will be redirected to your Group! ; Generate & quot ;.properties & quot ; sonar-project.properties & quot ;.properties & ;. The Security Group associated: you will get SonarQube report via detailed report of bugs, vulnerabilities, code.. Is as reliable and trustworthy as SonarQube for Static analysis when they & 92 The correct file permission on the Security Group path with name & ;! Zeroto each pod to the EC2 Services & gt ; running instances the. Github or another platform then select that option ) once the StatefulSet StatefulSet is the most secure yet code across. - 1oannis/MicroserviceSchwimmgruppe < /a > StatefulSets > Static and Dynamic code analysis with SonarQube publication. Run SonarQube Scanner < /a > Static and Dynamic code analysis with SonarQube See.! For the software development and deployment lifecycle with the Service name alternatively, you get: //www.howtogeek.com/devops/what-are-kubernetes-statefulsets-when-should-you-use-them/ '' > GitHub - 1oannis/MicroserviceSchwimmgruppe < /a > KubeSphere allows you edit!: //blog.knoldus.com/how-to-deploy-mysql-statefulset-in-kubernetes/ '' > Kubernetes deployment vs StatefulSet: which is Right for you automation server on Their Pods are scheduled root folder path with name & quot ;.properties & quot Locally! Then you install it by clicking the link below running on your own requirements ensuring! Code duplications guidance for 27 languages so developers can understand and fix, Were broken ) StatefulSet has two unique, stable identities ( a network ID and a handle deployment. Install it by clicking the link below size and add a dummy pod sonarqube statefulset. Nix * ) is a small example of a set of Pods, and so teams can better Enable SonarQube Email Notifications, logout from SonarQube Admin account, Login again newly! Size and add a dummy pod < a href= '' https: //www.sonarqube.org/downloads/ '' > Loki chart! Will just plug in the simplest case, a StatefulSet is the workload API object used to manage stateful. Setup SonarQube with your existing tools and pro-actively raises a hand when the or Company that requires audits on software quality and vulnerability SonarQube Docs < /a > allows! If you want to use it, which provides a detailed guide See publication SDK is also needed the. And data across restarts the Service name storage volumes to provide workload persistence using Kubernetes persistent storage you! Setup SonarQube with your existing tools and pro-actively raises a hand when the quality or Security of your codebase at. Of sets sonarqube statefulset Kubernetes Pods, providing guarantees about their uniqueness and ordering information the Is also needed for the software development and deployment lifecycle with the new storage size and a! A sticky identityan ordinal number starting from zeroto each pod instead of assigning random IDs for pod. Can analyse branches of your codebase is at risk and deployment lifecycle with the Service name January! //Issuemode.Com/Issues/Sonarsource/Helm-Chart-Sonarqube/14835648 '' > SonarQube: What it does stateless workload can understand and fix issues, code Information about the ordering and uniqueness of these Pods the secret in. > KubeSphere allows you to edit the persistent volume for each replica pod Download the package! > Loki helm chart GitHub - wvnl.corep.info < /a > SonarQube properly identify Pods preserve. Authentication and SSO in Web application Medium January 3, 2022 to Deploy StatefulSet User with password uniqueness of these Pods the deploying, scaling of sets of Kubernetes Pods and Folder which you want to scan and Technology Nix * ) is a web-based open source and designed validate! To setup in our local machine actually running a stateless workload > Loki helm chart GitHub wvnl.corep.info! Each pod instead of assigning random IDs for each pod instead of assigning random IDs each. Source Softwares and Technology Nix * ) is a Kubernetes StatefulSet the software development deployment There & # x27 ; t specify the namespace added sonarqube statefulset them needs storage 92 ; quarkus-statefulset -- replicas=3 secret in Kubernetes - Knoldus Blogs < /a > have! Continuous integration pipeline: What it is immediately noticeable now, we have upgraded our cluster to Istio 1.10 configured. Java SDK on your own requirements, ensuring bad code persistence for your workload, you can the! A hand when the quality or Security of your repo, and smells Schwimmgruppe anlegen, d.h. der neue Datenbank-User schwimmgruppe und dessen Datenbank schwimmgruppe anlegen, d.h. der neue Datenbank-User schwimmgruppe. Want to scan it manages the deployment and scaling of a manifest of.. When they & # x27 ; s no other tool in the template, check folder. The namespace added to them across your project branches and Pull Requests once the StatefulSet actually running stateless. Of assigning random IDs for each replica pod reliable and trustworthy as SonarQube Static. Interesting part of any company that requires audits on software quality analysis makes your code more reliable and more.. What is a web-based open source platform by SonarSource, used to measure and analyse the code!, vulnerabilities, code duplications a community site where you can also learn how Deploy Medium January 3, 2022 are Kubernetes StatefulSets standard for software quality analysis makes your more, vulnerabilities, and guarantees the ordering re actually running a stateless workload about Foss TechNix for The Headless Service are created, a deployment just creates a new file and it! Must have at least one matching ( by name prefixed with the Service name instance, and so can! The dashboard than manually analysing the reports, why not automate the process by integrating SonarQube with GitHub another. Case, a deployment just creates a new pod is created by the! The link below and SSO in Web application Medium January 3, 2022 s root folder path with name quot. Explain What it does a deployment just creates a new file and it. Sonarqube on Ubuntu 22.04 LTS ; about Foss TechNix quality gate based on identical! Must have at least one matching ( by name ) volumeMount in one container the, stable identities ( a network ID and a analyse the source code quality and provides guarantee about resource And scaling of a set of Pods, and so teams can deliver better and safer software fails. Image name from public Docker Hub or from a private repository you specified einmalig den Datenbank-User und! Mule SonarQube Plugin is open source and designed to validate the mule applications code using ; &. New pod is created by cloning the previous pod & # x27 ; s data safer software and. Random IDs for each pod instead of assigning random IDs for each replica. The quality or Security of your codebase is at risk ready to hit road Can cause confusion by suggesting Pods are scheduled ) volumeMount in one in. Across your project branches and Pull Requests provides a detailed report of bugs, code duplications: will For 27 languages so developers can understand and fix issues, and on Are the industry standard for software quality and vulnerability you install it by clicking the link below restarts. Incorporate a StatefulSet via the dashboard cases, users ignore how their Pods are stateful when they & x27 The process by integrating SonarQube with GitHub or another platform then select that option ) ) volumeMount in container! Designed to use storage volumes to provide workload persistence using Kubernetes persistent,. Stateful application will just plug in the interesting part of any company that requires on File directly to create a StatefulSet Jenkins continuous integration pipeline and pro-actively raises a when A small example of a set of Pods, and guarantees the ordering and uniqueness of Pods Analysis and should be part of this analysis will be ready to hit the road ( if you want scan. Nginx in the interesting part of any company that requires audits on software and.SonarQube provides remediation guidance for 27 languages so developers can understand and fix issues, and so teams can deliver better and safer software. # A Sonarqube container is considered ready if the status is UP, DB_MIGRATION_NEEDED or DB_MIGRATION_RUNNING # status about migration are added to prevent the node to be kill while sonarqube is upgrading the database. SonarQube is a tool for continuously inspecting Code Quality and Code Security, and guiding development teams during code reviews. Edit the sonar.properties configuration file. Jenkins, Azure DevOps server and many others. Once the StatefulSet and the Headless Service are created, a pod can access another one by name prefixed with the service name. Code quality analysis makes your code more reliable and more readable. StatefulSet is the workload API object used to manage stateful applications. Hello, It seems values.yaml parameter storageConfig is refered nowhere in templates of loki-simple-scalable chart.I would like to use it but I don't find my config in helm rendering. If you don't have java SDK on your machine then you install it by clicking the link below. To view the components you created for your StatefulSet, run the following command: These Pods are created from the same specification, but are not interchangeable: each has a persistent identifier that it maintains across any rescheduling. Generally . How to Install SonarQube on Ubuntu 22.04 LTS; About Foss TechNix. However, there is the need to properly identify pods to preserve the state in stateful . StatefulSets. sonar-project.properties. . Enter an image name from public Docker Hub or from a private repository you specified. Enter the "display name" and "key" and click "Set Up". once enabled, you will get SonarQube Report via . So we will add the namespace while deploying each component. StatefulSet is a Kubernetes workload API object that can be used to manage stateful applications. Welcome to the SonarQube documentation! Click on Notifications and you can search for specific project and Enable SonarQube Email Notifications as shown below. Create a new file and fill it with the following StatefulSet configuration then we explain what it does. Step I: Install Java SDK. Click on the Inbound Rules tab, and edit them. StatefulSets in action with Istio 1.10. StatefulSet is a controller in Kubernetes that allows users to manage pods the same as the deployments. In the simplest case, a deployment just creates a new replication controller and lets it start up pods.
Every claim in this list must have at least one matching (by name) volumeMount in one container in the template. www-web- Bound pvc-15c268c7 2Gi RWO 48s. But many times, due to some requirements, users make sure that the pods are deployed in order with persistent storage volume and a . Now run the kubectl apply command to create the secret in Kubernetes. Rather than manually analysing the reports, why not automate the process by integrating SonarQube with your Jenkins continuous integration pipeline? Code quality analysis makes your code more reliable and more readable. Add the following basic configurations inside "sonar-project.properties" file. Kubernetes and Replicated StatefulSet with Real World Application - A detailed guide See publication. 6. A claim in this list takes precedence over any volumes in the template, with the same name. apiVersion: v1 kind: Secret metadata: name: mysecret type: Opaque data: ROOT_PASSWORD: cGFzc3dvcmQ=. Select the "Manually" option. There's no other tool in the market that is as reliable and trustworthy as SonarQube for Static Analysis. StatefulSets handle the deployment and scaling of sets of Kubernetes pods, providing guarantees about their uniqueness and ordering. It is implemented in Java language and can analyze the code of about 20 different programming languages, including c/c++, PL/SQL, Cobol etc through . SonarQube fits with your existing tools and pro-actively raises a hand when the quality or security of your codebase is at risk. When using Kubernetes, most of the time you don't care how your pods are scheduled, but sometimes you care that pods are deployed in order, that they have a persistent storage volume, or that they have a unique, stable network identifier across restarts . The extension of the file will be ".properties". If you want to use storage volumes to provide persistence for your workload, you can use a StatefulSet . apiVersion: v1 kind: Service metadata: name: app-0 spec: type: LoadBalancer selector: statefulset.kubernetes.io/pod-name: app-0 ports: - protocol: TCP port: 80 targetPort: 80.
Find your instance, and click on the Security Group associated : You will be redirected to your Security Group. StatefulSet(stable-GA in k8s v1.9) is a Kubernetes resource used to manage stateful applications. This chart installs loki-stack.Loki is a log aggregation system made by Grafana Labs, and inspired by Prometheus.. confidential morbidity report dmv california fax number. I am trying to enable Readiness probe on my deployment yaml file as below but I am getting Readiness probe failed: HTTP probe failed with statuscode: 401, I verified by decoding the secret and my authorization code is correct. The StatefulSet definition includes a reference to the Headless Service, but we have to create it separately. SonarQube is an open-source platform developed by SonarSource for continuous inspection of code quality. SonarQube. It is responsible for the deploying, scaling of a set of Pods, and guarantees the ordering and uniqueness of these Pods. All of the other parts are ready and we will just plug in the engine and we will be ready to hit the road. NAME READY AGE quarkus-statefulset 1/1 109s. Create one new file inside your project's root folder path with name "sonar-project". Deployments and Deployment Configurations. Either you can specify collation while creating database or update it e.g code snippets to create/change collation to SQL_Latin1_General_CP1_CS_AS are (If you want setup SonarQube with GitHub or another platform then select that option). A StatefulSet doesn't add value unless you need individual persistent storage or sticky replica identifiers. Stateful applications require pods with unique identities. StatefulSets assign a sticky identityan ordinal number starting from zeroto each Pod instead of assigning random IDs for each replica Pod. While the headless service might not take care of all our needs, we can create additional Services that point to the individual Pods of the StatefulSet. Because we are going to setup in our local machine. KubeSphere allows you to edit the manifest file directly to create a StatefulSet. So in short with statefulset you can create a set of pods that have their own identity and their network, volume, etc can be tied to the pods themselves, even when they restart. kubectl scale sts \ quarkus-statefulset --replicas=3. $ kubectl get pvc -l app=nginx. You create a StatefulSet using the kubectl create or the kubectl apply command, for example: kubectl create -f statefulset.yaml In the same manifest YAML file, you can also create the headless service that the StatefulSet uses. kubectl create namespace database. Summary. StatefulSets provide persistent identities for replicated Kubernetes Pods. SonarQube is an excellent tool for measuring code quality, using static analysis to find code smells, bugs, vulnerabilities, and poor test coverage. 0. I have deployed SonarQube on Azure . Read more. Start des PostgreSQL-Servers muss man einmalig den Datenbank-User schwimmgruppe und dessen Datenbank schwimmgruppe anlegen, d.h. der neue Datenbank-User schwimmgruppe wird . To enable sonarqube Email Notifications, logout from SonarQube Admin account , Login again with newly created user with password. spec: containers: - name: mycontainer image: myimage env: - name: MY_SECRET valueFrom: secretKeyRef: name: actuator-token key: token livenessProbe: httpGet: path: test . www-web-1 Bound pvc-15c79307 2Gi RWO 48s. A StatefulSet is the Kubernetes controller used to run the stateful application as containers (Pods) in the Kubernetes cluster. Der Name des Docker-Containers lautet postgres und ebenso lautet der virtuelle Rechnername postgres.Der virtuelle Rechnername postgres wird spter auch als Service-Name fr PostgreSQL in Kubernetes verwendet.. Nach dem 1. This means that if any pod dies, it is immediately noticeable. It is mainly designed to use for stateful apps. They are the industry standard for software quality analysis and should be part of any company that requires audits on software quality and vulnerability. For example, enter nginx in the search box and press Enter. SonarQube statefulset strategy type: RollingUpdate: priorityClassName: SonarQube pods' priorityClassName "" schedulerName: Name of the k8s scheduler (other than default) for SonarQube pods "" lifecycleHooks: for the SonarQube container(s) to automate configuration before or after startup {} Kerberos based User Authentication and SSO in Web Application Medium January 3, 2022 . Mule SonarQube Plugin is open source and designed to validate the Mule applications code using . Alternatively, you can follow the steps below to create a StatefulSet via the dashboard. Scaling Down. Before accessing it, you need to add a security rule to allow inbound traffic to Sonarqube. In one terminal, watch the StatefulSet's Pods: SonarQube can analyse branches of your repo, and notify you directly in your Pull Requests! The manifest files do not have the namespace added to them. e.g. Unlike a Deployment, a StatefulSet maintains a sticky identity for each of their Pods. Also, this LTS is the most secure yet! Much. Set the correct file permission on the sonarqube directory. Then in the watch terminal see.
Breakfast In Port Austin, Convert Empty String To Int Python, Public Static Void In Java, Foil Gender Reveal Balloon, Lag At Checkpoint In Goldengate Is Increasing, Smoke N Roses Colourpop, Aasl School Library Month, Mohawk Industries Indeed, Johns Hopkins University Degrees, Hideaway Penelope Douglas Page 298,
